DaveW,
Those last two links remind me of a plant that I am familiar with:
Lewisia rediviva, commonly known as "bitterroot" although I grew up calling it a "rock rose". About that plant,
C.P.Lyons, Trees, Shrubs, and Flowers to know in Washington wrote:Bitterroot is an abundant spring bloom on the most exposed places throughout the dry Interior. It suddenly appears in May as if by magic and disappears in the same fashion. The rose-pink flowers hug close to the ground, their 10-15 petals spread wide in the sunshine. By the time the flowers appear the tufts of fleshy leaves have dried up. The root is thick and fleshy and was used in large quantities by the Indians. When the roots are boiled they swell up and become jelly-like. An early explorer says that a sack of roots would buy a good horse.
Very different taxon from the
Ariocarpus, but sounds like similar habits. They still strike me as looking like plants, though, when they're up and about.
These Lithops, on the other hand, still look like pretty pebbles. Maybe I just need to get my eyes adjusted.
--Rik