20X, Nikon CF Plan EPI ELWD versus Mitutoyo M Plan Apo

Have questions about the equipment used for macro- or micro- photography? Post those questions in this forum.

Moderators: Pau, rjlittlefield, ChrisR, Chris S.

rjlittlefield
Site Admin
Posts: 21198
Joined: Tue Aug 01, 2006 8:34 am
Location: Richland, Washington State, USA
Contact:

20X, Nikon CF Plan EPI ELWD versus Mitutoyo M Plan Apo

Post by rjlittlefield »

I had occasion tonight to test a couple of objectives: Nikon CF Plan EPI ELWD 20X NA 0.40 WD 11.0 mm versus a Mitutoyo M Plan Apo 20X NA 0.42 WD 20.0 mm.

To do a quick and dirty flash-to-compare, I pulled both images into Photoshop, layered the two images, and did an Edit > Auto-Align Layers.

Looking around the images, here's what I saw.

Whole frames. I didn't get the two tests framed exactly the same, but they were close.

Image

Image

100% crops, Nikon on the left, Mitutoyo on the right.

Just above image center:
Image Image

Near lower left corner:
Image Image

Near upper left corner:
Image Image

Conclusion is that the Mitutoyo 20X wins hands down. That's no surprise by reputation, but it's nice to see a head-to-head comparison.

Miscellaneous details: Canon T1i, Canon 580EX II flash at 1/16 power with Kleenex diffuser wrapped around the head, Canon EF 55-200mm zoom at 200mm, StackShot at 2 microns, Zerene Stacker PMax with no post-processing. Screen grabs by Snagit.

Edited to add: I tried reprocessing the Nikon stack with skip factor 2, so effectively at 4 microns focus step. Flash-to-compare showed slight focus banding, but I don't think I would have seen it in side-by-side comparison. Theoretical 1/4-lambda DOF at NA 0.40 and 550 nm is 3.4 microns. Same thing with the Mitutoyo produced somewhat more definite banding, definitely visible in side-by-side on careful study. Theoretical DOF at NA 0.42 is 3.1 microns. Conclusion is that the theoretical numbers work OK here.

--Rik

Yousef Alhabshi
Posts: 169
Joined: Fri Feb 04, 2011 3:06 am
Location: United Arab Emirates
Contact:

Post by Yousef Alhabshi »

Thanks Rik. Such kind of tests are always helpful & appreciated.

Post Reply Previous topicNext topic